There is a fine line between making a homage and an outright fake. Somewhere within that line, are watch builders like me. This is an example of a homage, but since it's not a 1 to 1 copy, it's not considered fake, in my eyes at least. Actually, it's not considered anything. It's a watch with no identity, no heritage, no brand, no value apart from the sum I paid for its parts.
While some welcome homage watches and even those modded ones where an original is slightly modified to look like something else, others are very critical. Take this watch for example. The Seiko SARB033 inspired me to make this watch.
.jpg) |
| My homage to the SARB033; 36mm case. |
 |
| An actual SARB033; 38mm case |
Looking closely at the above images, it is clear that I took inspiration from the SARB033, but aside from the shape of the hands and the approximate color of the dial, these have nothing in common. They are only linked by my claim that inspiration came from the Seiko, but the watch I made is its own watch. I specifically chose a dial that had no branding. The SARB033 has a date window, while my build has both a day and date complication. A complication that is very useful to me.
The cases don't even resemble one another. The SARB033 has a 38mm case while my watch has a 36mm case that obviously looks like a case from that brand that has a crown.
Honestly, my build looks more like the SNKL23 than the SARB033. A fact I'm not happy about. My objective was to homage a watch that, for me, is out of my reach, but I ended up making a watch look like a budget watch that I could afford. While my watch is slightly cheaper than the SNKL23, I went to all the effort to put this thing together, and if I factor in the build cost, it might not be that far from the SNKL23's retail price.
 |
| Seiko SNKL23 |
There are a few features that my watch has that the iconic SNKL23 does not.
- My watch has a Sapphire crystal. The SNKL23 has hardlex.
- My watch is powered by an NH36, also made by Seiko, but has hacking and hand winding - both if which the 7s26 in the SNKL23 doesn't have.
- My watch has a screw down crown. Which means better water resistance. I can potentially go diving with my watch.
I'm not saying that my build is better than Seiko. It may be called a homage, but it sure can't be called a fake. The above features I mentioned are surely things that even the most dedicated Seiko fanatic would want for their "originals".
For the critical watch enthusiast, my build may not be to their liking. They may outright say that it's a fake due to the fact that it was originally built with the SARB033 as an inspiration, but then again, all modern watches were inspired by something that was made long ago.
The only consolation I have is that Seiko still made some money from my build because of the NH36 movement that drives my watch. I'm not exactly sure what Seiko thinks of my build.
Is it a fake?
